Selling: what each route pays, what it costs you, and what gets reported
Estate sale company, consignment, auction, online marketplace, yard sale and dealer buyout each take something different. This chapter shows how much estate sale companies charge, how to compare what a route leaves you after its fees and your hours, and what gets reported to the IRS when you sell things from your house.
This is not tax advice. We state what the federal rules require you to keep or file, never what any of it does to your tax bill. Ask a tax preparer about your own return.
- Start here: the essentials
- Six routes, and what each is for
- What each route takes
- Net, hours and net per hour
- Meeting a buyer, and what you can't sell
- When an appraisal is worth buying
- What gets reported
- See it: a drop-leaf table and three quotes
- Practice: one lot, three quotes, one record
- Your situation
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Choose a route by what it leaves you after its fees and your hours, with the fees in writing. If you are selling one item you own, the list is one line, the written terms are the platform's fee page, and the four steps still apply.
- List the lot and a rough count. Name what you want to sell and how many pieces there are (six routes).
- Get written terms from the route you favor. For an online sale the platform's fee page is the terms. For a company, ask for the contract before the sale (what each route takes).
- Enter the fees and your own hours in What each route pays. Use your own estimate of what the goods will bring (net, hours and net per hour).
- Record the first sale in Donation and sales records. Write the date, the price, the fees and how you came to own the item (what gets reported).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes for the list and one written quote. Done when: one route is chosen with its fees in writing, and the first sale or the decision is recorded.
Six routes, and what each is for Understand
A route in this chapter is a way of turning a pile of belongings into money. Six are in common use. They differ in who does the work, who sets the price and what is taken before the money reaches you. The table says what each is for. Where we found a fetched page that supports a statement, the cell names it. Where we found none, the cell says so, and the sections below give the questions to ask and the arithmetic to do instead.
| Route | What it is | What it suits, by volume and value | What we found |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estate sale company | A company prices the goods, holds a sale at the house over a few days and takes a share of what sells. | A whole household, or most of one. Checkbook says a home with $3,000 or more in furnishings, clothing and other goods merits a sale. The EstateSales.NET survey says 20.51 percent of the companies it surveyed would accept a $5,000 minimum and 14 percent set $10,000. | Published commission figures, with who published them, below. |
| Consignment | A shop or an operator sells your goods and keeps a share, usually item by item. | Items worth a shop's floor space. | No fetched source states consignment terms or how long goods sit. Checkbook warns that an estate sale company that also runs a consignment shop can be a red flag. Ask the questions in the table further down. |
| Auction | An auction house or an estate sale company's online or live auction sells to the highest bid. The buyer pays a premium on top. | Checkbook says an in-person estate auction is a good option for a rural home unlikely to draw foot traffic, that a company may send a few top items, such as a painting by a noted artist, to auction, and that estate sale companies' online auctions accept online bidding and often require local pickup. | One house's published buyer's premium. No consignor rate is stated in the terms we read. |
| Online marketplace | You list, photograph, answer, pack, ship or hand over each item yourself on eBay, Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist. | Items you can describe and photograph in a listing. Checkbook advises researching prices on Facebook Marketplace and eBay before a do-it-yourself sale. | The fee pages for eBay and Facebook Marketplace as read today, and Craigslist's safety pages. |
| Yard sale | You hold the sale yourself. | Many low-priced items. The nearest source is Checkbook's description of a do-it-yourself estate sale, which it says will probably bring in less revenue and lets you keep all the proceeds. | No fetched source on yard sale takings or hours. CPSC says its laws apply to people holding yard sales (see meeting a buyer). |
| Dealer buyout | One buyer takes the lot, or a named part of it, for an agreed price. | A short deadline. Checkbook describes a buyout by an estate sale operator as the choice when time is too short for a sale, and says you will not make as much as with an estate sale. | No fetched source on a dealer's offer for individual goods. Ask the questions below. |
A commission is a percentage of the sale price that the seller's agent keeps. A consignment is an arrangement in which someone else sells your goods and keeps a share. A buyout is a lump sum for everything, paid before the buyer has sold any of it. These are our one-sentence definitions for this chapter.
The table does not rank the routes, and no route wins in general. Which one fits depends on facts about your goods and your time that the manual cannot see: how many pieces, what a buyer would pay for them, how soon they must be gone and how many hours you have.
What each route takes Understand
Every route takes something before the money reaches you. Some of it is a percentage, some is a flat fee, and some is a cost you carry yourself. A headline percentage is not the whole cost, so each subsection below lists what else to ask about.
Estate sale companies: the published commission figures
We found no source that calls any commission a standard. The page from EstateSales.org says there are no estate sale industry standards set for commissions, and it is written for liquidators. The table lists every figure we found, who published it and whether that publisher makes money from estate sales. We read each page on 2026-11-13. We state no going rate.
| Publisher and date | Figure as published | What it adds | Does the publisher profit from estate sales? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Checkbook.org, a nonprofit; page last updated June 2026; Washington, DC area | "30 to 50 percent is typical." Example: 40 percent for a smaller estate ($3,000 to $5,000), 30 percent for a large one. | Minimum sale amounts and fees, typically $500 to $3,000. Some companies charge extra for post-sale clear-out and others include it. Card processing costs 3 to 5 percent. | No. The page says it takes no advertising or referral fees. It sells subscriptions to its ratings. |
| Minnesota Attorney General, consumer guide; undated | "Commissions can range as high as 30-40 percent." | Ask about moving, appraisals, security, trash removal, cleaning and advertising. Estate sale companies are required to be bonded in Minnesota. | No, a state agency. The guide is about Minnesota. |
| EstateSales.NET, 2023 industry survey of 756 businesses in 38 states | 35 percent and 40 percent were the most common rates, with 10 to 60 percent as the range. A 2021 average of 37 percent. | Minimum gross revenue: 20.51 percent of respondents would accept $5,000 and 14 percent set $10,000. | Yes. It is a listing site that sells to estate sale companies, and the respondents are the companies. |
| EstateSales.org, "Estate Sale Fees and Commission"; undated | Examples of 30 or 40 percent, with 15 to 20 percent for specific items, and a 90 percent commission described as not uncommon for an extremely labor-intensive sale. | Some companies charge clean-up, labor, advertising, security and cancellation separately. | Yes. It sells listing and software services to liquidators, and the page is written for them. |
Read the four rows together and they overlap without agreeing. The figures run from 10 percent to 90 percent depending on who is speaking and for what kind of sale. The nonprofit says 30 to 50 percent is typical, the state agency says as high as 30 to 40, and the survey of businesses that profit from sales gives 35 and 40 percent as the most common rates. None of them describes your house. The number that matters is the one in the quote you hold. Published figures, not a standard
The percentage also sits beside other charges. Ask which of these the quote includes, and write the answers into the contract:
- A minimum fee or minimum sale amount, and what happens if the sale brings less.
- Clean-out or hauling after the sale, and what happens to goods that did not sell: donation, another sale or the landfill.
- Advertising, labor, security and a cancellation fee, if the company bills them separately.
- Card processing, and who pays when a card payment is disputed.
What the contract should say
Several of these sources say to get the terms in writing before the sale, and they agree on much of what belongs there. No statute is cited in any of them. A contract here means the written agreement between you and the company. Combining the lists from Checkbook, the Minnesota Attorney General and EstateSales.org gives this set of things to find in it. Practitioner and agency advice
- Fees: the percentage, any sliding scale, any minimum, and every other charge.
- Who prices items, whether you may change a price or pull an item, and whether staff may discount a marked price without your consent.
- What is in the sale. Checkbook says many agreements treat everything in the house as for sale once signed, so take out what you want to keep before you sign.
- Payment: a deadline, a subtotal of proceeds at the end of each sale day, and a ban on the company using your proceeds before it pays you. Checkbook says most companies pay within two to three weeks. EstateSales.NET's guide to hiring a company cites a survey saying 71 percent settle within a week. Those two sources differ, so the deadline in your contract is the one that counts.
- Records: an itemized list of each item's actual sale price, plus an itemized list of donated or unsold goods.
- Unsold goods: where they go and what it costs.
- Staff and the company's own purchases: the Minnesota guide says staff should need your consent before buying items or bringing in their own goods.
- Insurance and, where your state requires it, bonding. The Minnesota guide says to ask for a copy. We do not say whether your state requires it; that is a question for your state's consumer protection office.
- Every oral promise, written out. The Minnesota guide says a company may not honor a promise that is not in the contract.
Then get three written contracts and compare the totals. Ask each company for a written proposal showing how it calculates its fees, as Checkbook advises. Enter each company's percentage, minimum and flat fees into What each route pays, with the same estimate of what the goods will bring, so the three differ only in what each takes. The company with the lowest percentage is not necessarily the company that leaves you the most; the example below shows one case where it does not.
Comparing three contracts line by line
Put the three contracts side by side and give each clause a row. For each row, write what each company's contract says, or "silent" if it does not say. A silent row is a question for that company, and its answer goes into the contract. The rows to use are the list above, plus these taken from the EstateSales.org contract guide, which is written for liquidators and is therefore a view from the other side of the table: who supplies the cash bank for change, how missing or removed items and indemnification are handled, how cancellation and bad weather are handled, whether staging or shipping is included, and how the contract ends. Practitioner advice
Read each contract's wording on what you did not plan: a hidden treasure that turns out to be worth far more than its tag, an item that goes missing and a dispute with a buyer. These are three of the points the EstateSales.org guide lists. A contract that answers them in writing is easier to compare than one that is silent. We do not say what is fair for any of them.
Auction: the hammer price is not what you get
At an auction, the hammer price is the highest bid the auctioneer accepts for a lot. The buyer's premium is a charge the buyer pays the auction house on top of the hammer price. Christie's conditions of sale for New York, in the file dated 1 September 2026, are one example of the structure. Under those terms the premium is 28 percent of the hammer price up to and including $2,000,000, 22 percent on the part over that up to and including $8,000,000, and 15 percent on the part above. Christie's says it acts as the seller's agent unless it owns a lot, and that its estimates do not include the premium or taxes. One house's terms
Two consequences matter for a seller. First, the buyer pays the premium, and the file says the buyer pays it to Christie's. A buyer who bids $1,000 pays $1,280 under that 28 percent tier; the extra $280 is a charge the buyer owes the house, and it is not part of the hammer price. Second, Christie's reports sales totals as hammer price plus buyer's premium, and says those totals do not reflect costs, financing fees or seller's credits. A reported total is therefore not what the consignor received.
We found no consignor rate in those terms or anywhere else we read, so we state none. Checkbook says live-auction operators' fee structures are similar to onsite estate sales, with a sliding scale most common, and that is a description of a structure, not a figure. For any auction, ask the house for these in writing: the seller's commission and every other seller's charge, the premium's effect on bidding, the reserve if any, the date the auction is held, and the date you are paid. Do the arithmetic on the hammer price less the seller's charges. Ask the auction house
Online marketplaces: the fee, plus what the base includes, plus hours
Fees change without notice, so we give each one with the page and the date we read it, and the page is what counts.
| Marketplace | The fee as the page states it | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| eBay, read 2026-11-13; the page carries no date | A final value fee from 2.5 to 15.3 percent depending on category, plus a per order fee of $0.30 for orders of $10.00 or less and $0.40 for orders over $10.00. For an individual seller in "most categories (exceptions apply)": 13.6 percent of the sale up to $7,500 per item and 2.35 percent on the part over. | The fee base includes the item, shipping and sales tax. The page names exceptions such as books and magazines (15.3 percent), trading cards, most jewelry and watches, women's bags and handbags, guitars and basses, sneakers over $150, heavy equipment and NFTs. It does not name furniture, home and garden, pottery and glass, antiques or general collectibles, so we state no rate for them. Most casual sellers pay no listing fee, and an individual seller gets 250 free listings a month. |
| Facebook Marketplace: Meta's shipping payouts help page states the fee, and its merchant policies state what it is calculated on; read 2026-11-13; no date on either page | 10 percent per transaction, minimum $0.80, for sales checked out on the platform and shipped. | The fee applies to the whole transaction, shipping and applicable taxes included. We did not find a page that states the fee for a local pickup sale, so we do not say it is free. |
| Craigslist | The two safety pages we read state no fee and are about safety, so we state none. | Craigslist advises dealing locally, face to face, and treats payment before meeting as a warning sign. See meeting a buyer. |
An example of why the base matters, using a rate we made up to keep the arithmetic easy and not any marketplace's rate: at 10 percent plus a $0.40 order fee, an item priced at $150 with $50 in shipping and $10.50 in sales tax has a base of $210.50. The fee is $21.05 plus $0.40, which is $21.45. A calculation that applies 10 percent to the $150 item alone gets $15.40 and understates the fee by $6.05. What each route pays applies its percentage to the gross you enter, so for eBay or Facebook, work out the fee on the whole amount the buyer pays and enter it in the flat fee box.
Consignment, yard sale and dealer buyout: questions to ask, and arithmetic to do
We found no fetched source that states the terms of a consignment shop, the offers a dealer makes for household goods or the takings of a yard sale. We state none. The arithmetic is yours. For each of the three, get these answers in writing, then enter them in What each route pays.
| Route | Ask | Do |
|---|---|---|
| Consignment | What share does the shop keep? How long are goods held, and what happens to an item that does not sell: pickup, a lower price or donation? Who pays if an item is damaged or stolen? When are you paid, and how do you see what sold? | Estimate the gross for the items the shop would take, not the lot. Enter its share and your trips to deliver and collect as hours. |
| Yard sale | What does a permit or a sign cost where you live? Who helps, and for how many hours? What happens to what is left at the end of the day? | Count the hours for sorting, pricing, setting up, being there and taking down. Decide before the day where the leftovers go. |
| Dealer buyout | Is the offer for the whole lot or named pieces? Will the dealer put it in writing, with the date they take everything away? Does the dealer remove the goods, and does the price change if you take some out? | The offer is the gross and it is a single figure. Compare it with the net of the other routes, not their gross. |
Net, hours and net per hour Understand
Net is what a route leaves you: what the goods bring, less the commission, less every other fee, less the cost of shipping, supplies and travel that you pay. Net per hour is the net divided by your own hours. Both are your arithmetic on your own estimates. We make no claim about how much longer any route takes than another, because we found no source that measures it.
Count the hours honestly, because the routes differ in where the hours fall. Include listing, photographing, answering messages, packing and shipping or meeting a buyer, as well as being at the house for a walk-through, meeting each company, being present for the sale and arranging what happens to the leftovers. Time one listing from start to finish the way the timed trial times a container, then multiply by the number of listings. A route that leaves more money per item and takes many more hours can leave less per hour, and the reverse is true too. Only your own numbers show which. Test it
Your own hours are the hours you would otherwise spend sorting. If you have a closing date, hours spent selling are hours not spent on the next room. The plan and the pace is where that trade is counted.
One more cost sits outside the arithmetic: what is left when the route is done. A sale that does not move an item leaves it in your house. Decide where unsold goods go before you start, whether that is Donating, a second route or a haul. Checkbook says estate sale companies commonly cut prices over a sale, for example by 25 percent Saturday morning, 50 percent Saturday afternoon and 75 percent Sunday for a Friday-to-Sunday event. That is an example from one source, and the contract's own schedule is the one that applies.
The tool in What each route pays reports net and net per hour under the fees you enter. It does not say which route to use, and no route wins in general. The facts about your goods that decide it are how many pieces there are, what buyers would pay for them, how much of it is worth a buyer's trip, how soon it must be gone, how many hours you have and what happens to what does not sell. None of those is known until a buyer or a company has seen the goods. Treat a ranking as the result of your estimates, and change an estimate to see how much it moves the ranking. Ask the route
Meeting a buyer, and what you can't sell Understand
Two checks come before a sale. The first is about what you are allowed to sell. CPSC's guide for resellers says its laws apply to individuals holding yard sales and flea markets, and that it is illegal to sell any recalled product. The same guide says those who give used products away cannot sell or donate products that do not meet the law's requirements. Check an item against CPSC's recall list before you list it. What can't go to the thrift store covers the rule and what to do with the item. Ask the authority Source: CPSC, Resellers Guide to Selling Safer Products, version of February 2025.
The second check is about the buyer. Craigslist's safety pages say:
- Meet in a public place, such as a bank or a police department. Some police departments have areas set aside for buying and selling. We have no national link for these; search your own police department's name with "safe exchange zone".
- Do not meet in a secluded place or invite strangers into your home. Be especially careful with high-value items. Tell a friend or family member where you are going and consider a companion.
- Deal locally, face to face. Do not pay or accept payment before meeting. Wire transfers, gift cards and cashier's check deposits are described as scams, and escrow requests can be one. Do not share financial or personal information such as a Social Security number.
Sources: Craigslist, meeting in person and Craigslist, avoiding scams. Craigslist's advice The same advice suits any sale to a stranger. If an item is heavy or high, get help to move it and stop before you are tired.
When an appraisal is worth buying Understand
An appraisal is a paid opinion of an object's value written by someone who is not buying it. We do not price any object here. This section says when one is worth asking for and what the IRS means by a qualified one. Our reasoning
Our reading is that an appraisal can be worth buying in four cases:
- You suspect one piece is worth far more than the rest, and the route you favor prices a whole house quickly. Checkbook says the best estate sale companies employ staff with appraisal skills to price items, so ask what that means for your piece and what it costs. A separate appraisal can give you a figure to compare with a company's price or a dealer's offer.
- Heirs are dividing by value. A method that balances values needs a value for each item. Passing things to people compares the methods.
- A donation of similar items over $5,000 needs one under the IRS rules. Donating states the tiers.
- A lawyer or preparer asks for a value at a date, such as the value at someone's death. Ask them what they need before you hire an appraiser; the date and the standard can matter.
We found no source for what an appraisal costs, so we give no figure. Ask for the fee in writing before the work starts.
What a qualified appraisal and a qualified appraiser are
The IRS defines both in Publication 526, on pages 33 and 34, for the purpose of a charitable contribution deduction. We use the definitions as the manual's reference point for what the word "qualified" asks for, and we do not say they govern a sale. A qualified appraisal is a document that:
- is made, signed and dated by a qualified appraiser, following the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP);
- meets the Treasury regulation named in the publication;
- has a valuation effective date no earlier than 60 days before the date of the contribution and no later than that date; and
- does not involve a prohibited appraisal fee.
A qualified appraiser is a person with verifiable education and experience in valuing the type of property. The person has either earned an appraisal designation from a generally recognized professional appraiser organization, or has met minimum education requirements and 2 or more years of experience. The person also regularly prepares appraisals for pay. The source is IRS Publication 526, the edition for preparing 2025 returns. Legal requirement, for a deduction
USPAP is the standard of The Appraisal Foundation, which describes it as the national standards for real estate and other appraisal, including personal property. Its USPAP page is a product page, and the Foundation sells the document. Two professional bodies run directories you can search: the International Society of Appraisers, whose page says its Certified and Accredited members are qualified appraisers as the Appraisal Foundation defines them, and the American Society of Appraisers, whose directory searches by location and discipline, including personal property. We list them as places to look, not as recommendations. Ask any appraiser what credential they hold and what standard the report follows.
An offer to buy is not an appraisal
A dealer's or a company's offer to buy is not a qualified appraisal under the definition above. This is our reading of the definition. The definition asks for a document made, signed and dated by a qualified appraiser, with a valuation date and a standard behind it. An offer is a price from the party on the other side of the sale, and nothing in it is a signed appraisal. Checkbook also warns that an estate sale company that runs a consignment shop may undersell the best items so it can resell them in the shop. A buyer's price tells you what that buyer will pay, and nothing more.
What gets reported Understand
This section states what the IRS pages say about reporting. It does not say what any of it does to a return. For that, ask a tax preparer. Ask the authority
Form 1099-K
A Form 1099-K is a statement a payment platform sends about the payments it processed for you. The IRS's page says third party settlement organizations report when the total payments exceed $20,000 in more than 200 transactions. The same page says you may receive a form even when your payments or transactions are less than that, and that you must report all income. So a form can reach someone who sold only a few things. Legal requirement Source: Understanding your Form 1099-K, last reviewed 13 November 2026.
A personal item sold at a loss, and at a gain
The IRS's page on what to do with a Form 1099-K describes a personal item as something owned for personal use, with a car, furniture, stereo, jewelry and silverware as examples. It says a loss on the sale of a personal item can't be deducted. It says you can zero out the reported gross amount, either at the top of Schedule 1 (Form 1040) or on Form 8949, which carries to Schedule D. A gain on a personal item goes on Form 8949 and Schedule D. Publication 544 says the same about loss ("Loss from the sale or exchange of property held for personal use is not deductible"), and so does IRS Topic 409. Box 1a on a Form 1099-K is not adjusted for fees, shipping and similar items, and the page says those can be taken off the gross amount. Sources: What to do with Form 1099-K (27 July 2026), Publication 544 (page 54) and Topic 409 (9 November 2026). Legal requirement
Basis, and what it means for inherited and gifted things
Basis is the figure the IRS uses to measure gain or loss on a sale. Publication 551 says you must keep accurate records of everything that affects it. For things you did not buy, the basis comes from somewhere else:
- Inherited property. Publication 551 says the basis is generally the fair market value at the date of the person's death, or the value on the alternate valuation date if the estate's personal representative chooses that. It says a beneficiary may receive a Schedule A (Form 8971) from the executor when the estate filed Form 706. Without one, the page says basis can be the appraised value at the date of death for state inheritance tax. Publication 544 says inherited property is treated as held longer than 1 year, however long you held it. (Pub. 551, page 15; Pub. 544, page 54.)
- Gifted property. If the fair market value at the time of the gift is less than the donor's adjusted basis, Publication 551 says the basis for gain is the donor's adjusted basis and the basis for loss is the value at the time of the gift. A sale between the two gives neither gain nor loss. (Pub. 551, pages 14 and 15.)
What that means for your own return is a question for your preparer. What you can do now is write down, for each item you sell, how you came to own it and when, and keep anything that states its value at that time. Source: Publication 551, revised December 2025. Legal requirement
The IRS says to keep records relating to property until the period of limitations expires for the year in which you dispose of it, and gives 3 years as the general period. Its page on how long to keep records lists exceptions, so check it or ask your preparer which period applies to you. The sales records have a column for each fact above.
The basis question for inherited items, in more detail
For a house full of ordinary household goods, the pieces that raise the question are the few with a real value at the date of death. Four facts matter and none is ours to settle. Did the estate file Form 706? If so, the executor may owe beneficiaries a Schedule A. Was there an appraisal for state inheritance tax? Publication 551 says that value may stand in when no Schedule A arrives. Did the personal representative choose the alternate valuation date? Publication 551 names that choice. Was an item given to the person who died in the last year of their life by you or your spouse? Publication 551 says the usual date-of-death rule does not apply to appreciated property in that case, and the basis is the person's adjusted basis. We do not say which of these applies. The executor and a tax preparer settle them. If the estate has no executor yet, see The three situations.
As our own practice, not a rule, keep a photograph and a one-line description of each item that might have a notable value, with the date of death written beside it.
State sales tax
Whether your state's sales tax applies to a private sale of used goods is a question for your state's revenue department, and we state no rule or figure. We found no national source. Facebook's help page says Facebook does not handle taxes for local pickup, and eBay's page says its fee base includes sales tax. Neither tells you what your state requires of you as a seller. Ask the department by name, say that you are selling used household goods from your home, and write down the answer and the date you asked.
This chapter states reporting rules from IRS pages. It does not say whether a sale of yours produces a gain or loss, whether any figure is reportable on your return, or what an estate owes. Those depend on facts the manual cannot see: what you paid or inherited, the date, what you sold it for and what else is on your return. Questions about the estate itself, such as who may sell, what an executor must file and who reports what, belong to a probate lawyer and, for the return, to an accountant or tax preparer.
Selling before authority is settled
If the belongings were someone else's, such as a person who has died, a sale can start before anyone has the authority to make it. A sale that starts before the will and the court have settled who may act can cause a problem this manual cannot fix. Settle who has authority first. Clearing a house that isn't yours sets out the order of work, and The three situations explains authority. A probate lawyer and the county clerk settle the questions. Ask the authority
See it: a drop-leaf table and three quotes See it
Dana, Ray and Priya Haverford. Their father died in March, and the house in Scranton, Pennsylvania sells in nine weeks. Dana lives twenty minutes away, Ray four hours and Priya in Oregon. They disagree about the workshop tools and about a yellow bowl.
Known: the nine weeks and the distances. Assumed (ours, for the example): the lot has about 120 pieces, and Dana, who lives closest, will do the legwork. Priya believes a drop-leaf table might be worth much more than the rest of the lot. Dana collected three offers. Company A quotes 40 percent with clean-out included. Company B quotes 30 percent with a $1,000 minimum commission and a $400 clean-out fee. A dealer offers $900 for the whole lot and removal. Dana estimates 6 hours for either company and 2 hours for the dealer. Open: what the lot will actually bring, whether the table is valuable, whether there is a will and who is executor.
The arithmetic. Suppose, as an estimate and not a prediction, that the lot brings $3,000 at a sale. Company A takes $1,200, which leaves $1,800 net, or $300 an hour over 6 hours. Company B's 30 percent would be $900, but the minimum is $1,000, so it takes $1,000 plus $400, which leaves $1,600 net, or about $267 an hour. The dealer's $900 is $450 an hour over 2 hours. By net per hour the dealer ranks first, and by net the dealer ranks last. At a $5,000 estimate the order between the two companies flips: A leaves $3,000 and B leaves $3,100, because B's percentage is lower and its minimum no longer bites. The company with the lower percentage was not the better offer until the estimate rose.
What they do next. Priya asks for an appraisal of the table from an appraiser found through the directories, before any contract is signed, because the contracts treat everything in the house as for sale once signed unless it is taken out. They also decide who takes the table with the method from Passing things to people, and they ask the lawyer whether anyone may sign a contract yet. They ask each company for the three contract terms from the list above and for its schedule for unsold goods.
Conclusion, under these assumptions: no route wins on every measure; the dealer wins on hours and loses on the total. The facts that settle it are the estimate of what the lot brings, the table's appraised value and the answer from the probate lawyer and the county clerk about who may sell. None of those is settled in the example.
- Checkbook.org, estate sales: a nonprofit's questions to ask a company, the contract advice and the alternatives, including buyouts and auctions.
- Minnesota Attorney General, avoiding estate sale scams: a state agency's list of what a contract should include.
- IRS, what to do with Form 1099-K: loss on a personal item, gain, and Box 1a.
- Craigslist, meeting in person: how to meet a buyer.
Practice: one lot, three quotes, one record Practice
Minimum: one lot listed, one written quote or fee page, and one row in the sales records. Time: about 30 minutes for the list and the first quote, plus the days it takes quotes to arrive. Materials: the inventory or a list, a phone for photos, and What each route pays.
- List the lot. Write what you want to sell, a rough count, and what you want to keep. Take out what you want to keep before you ask any company for a quote.
- Get three written quotes, or one fee page for each online route you consider. Ask for the percentage, any minimum, every other charge, the payment deadline and what happens to unsold goods.
- Enter each into What each route pays with the same estimate of what the goods bring and your own hours for each. Change the estimate once to see whether the order moves.
- Choose a route, or choose to ask more. If a clause is silent, ask in writing and put the answer in the contract.
- Record the first sale in the sales records: date, item, price, fees and shipping, and how and when you came to own the item.
Put the three contracts side by side, one row per clause, as in the Go deeper section on contracts. For an item you inherited, add what you know of its value at the date of death.
Your situation Your situation
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Is there a written quote or a dated fee page for the route you chose?
- Does the contract say what is in the sale, who prices, when you are paid and where unsold goods go?
- Did you enter your own hours, not only the fees?
- Does the record for each sale carry the date, price, fees and how you came to own the item?
- If the belongings were someone else's, has the question of authority been asked first?
Worked example
The Haverfords hold three quotes and compare net and net per hour on the same estimate. The criteria are met for the quotes and the hours. They are not yet met for authority and for the table, which wait on the probate lawyer, the county clerk and an appraiser.
Common mistakes
- Comparing percentages. If two quotes differ in minimums or clean-out fees, the lower percentage can still leave less. Enter both in the tool.
- Reading an auction total as what you got. A reported total includes the buyer's premium. Ask for the seller's charges.
- Calling an offer an appraisal. An offer to buy is a price from a buyer. Ask for a signed appraisal if you need one.
- Leaving the item in the contract. A piece you want to keep or divide is in the sale unless you take it out.
- Not writing down how you got it. A sale record without the item's origin cannot answer the basis question later.
What is still unresolved
What a sale does to your return belongs to a tax preparer. Who may sell a dead person's things belongs to a probate lawyer and the county clerk. Whether a thing is worth appraising belongs to a qualified appraiser. We found no source for consignment terms, dealer offers or yard sale takings, so the arithmetic for those is yours. Anything that cannot legally be sold is in What can't go to the thrift store.