Papers, records and the data still on the devices
Paper is the slowest category in the house and is usually left to last. This chapter sorts it into four piles, says how long the IRS says to keep tax records, and covers the phones, computers and printers that hold data.
Start here Essentials
Do one box of paper and one walk through the house for devices. A box takes about half an hour, and the walk about fifteen minutes.
- Make four piles from one box of paper: keep permanently, keep for a stated period, destroy securely, recycle (the four piles).
- Pull anything with an account number into the destroy pile, unless the owner has died, in which case nothing goes in it yet (the destroy pile).
- List every device in the house that stores data: phones, tablets, computers, drives, memory cards, printers and copiers (the data still on the devices).
- Mark each device's status in the inventory: listed, backed up, cleared or still in use.
Minimum time: about 45 minutes in all. Done when: one box of paper is in four piles and every device in the house is on a list.
Why paper is slow Understand
Paper is the slowest category in most houses, and it is usually left to the last week. Each sheet might matter for a reason you cannot see from the front of it. A bank statement can be a tax record, a proof of an address or the only trace of a closed account. Furniture can be judged at a glance. A sheet of paper has to be read, and a box of them is a reading job. Our reasoning
That is why the plan for papers should not rest on a rate taken from another category. The rate you measured on a shelf of books may not hold for a box of paper. Time one box before you plan the rest, as The plan and the pace describes, and when the arithmetic does not work, the order in what to cut first says what to stop sorting. Boxes of paper are heavy. Use small boxes, get help lifting, and stop before you are tired.
This chapter handles the papers that belong to you. If the owner of the papers has died, read Clearing a house that isn't yours first. The papers decide who may do what, and nothing should be shredded until that is settled.
The four piles Understand
Every sheet of paper ends in one of four places. We use the same four piles for every box, so that a decision is one gesture and not a debate. The four piles are our own grouping; no source we found defines them. Our grouping
| Pile | What goes in it | What decides how long |
|---|---|---|
| Keep permanently | Papers that are the only proof of something lasting and slow to replace: identity and family records, ownership papers, military discharge papers (see papers with their own reasons to keep). | No period is set here. The office that issued the paper, or a professional named in the next section, says whether a replacement is possible. |
| Keep for a stated period | Records tied to a tax return, and papers a creditor, insurer or other party may want later. | For tax records, the IRS periods below. For the rest, the party that may ask. |
| Destroy securely | Papers you are done with that carry an account number, a Social Security number, a signature or medical details. | Your own judgment, using the test below. Wait if the owner has died. |
| Recycle | Paper with nothing personal on it: catalogs, manuals for things you no longer own, old calendars. | Your local recycling program. The rule is local. |
The keep-for-a-period pile: what the IRS says
The IRS page on how long to keep records says to keep the records that support an income, deduction or credit on a return until the period of limitations for that return runs out. That is the IRS's own term, and we do not interpret it further. It also says that a return filed before the due date is treated as filed on the due date, and that you should keep copies of the returns you file. The periods it lists are these (IRS, How long should I keep records?): IRS guidance
| Situation | The IRS page says to keep records |
|---|---|
| None of the situations below applies | 3 years |
| You file a claim for credit or refund after filing your return | 3 years from the date you filed the original return, or 2 years from the date you paid the tax, whichever is later |
| You claim a loss from worthless securities or a bad debt deduction | 7 years |
| You omit income you should have reported, and it is more than 25 percent of the gross income on your return | 6 years |
| You do not file a return | Indefinitely |
| You file a fraudulent return | Indefinitely |
| Employment tax records | At least 4 years after the tax becomes due or is paid, whichever is later |
| Property records (for example, what you paid for a house or an asset and what you spent on it) | Until the period of limitations expires for the year in which you dispose of the property, because you need them to work out gain or loss on its sale |
Notice the last row if you are selling a house as part of this job. The records that show what the house cost and what was spent on it are not on a three-year clock that started when you bought it. The page ties them to the year the property is disposed of. What those records do to a tax bill is a question for a tax preparer, and we do not compute it. Ask the authority
The same page adds one more instruction that matters for a downsizer: do not discard records once they are no longer needed for tax purposes until you have checked whether other purposes require keeping them longer. It names insurance companies and creditors as examples of parties that may require longer retention than the IRS does.
The IRS periods cover tax records. They are not a shredding schedule for the whole house. Deeds, titles, certificates, military discharge papers, medical records and anything that supports an insurance claim or a debt have their own reasons to be kept, listed in the next section, and the IRS page does not govern them. Whether a particular record is a tax record for your return is a question for a tax preparer; where a paper is a legal document, the question belongs to the issuing office or a lawyer. Ask the authority
The destroy pile
We found no source that states which papers a household must shred, so the test is ours. Put a paper in the destroy pile if it carries an account number, a Social Security number, a signature, a date of birth beside a name, or medical information, and it has nothing left to prove. If you are unsure whether it has nothing left to prove, it goes in the keep-for-a-period pile with a note, and you decide with the box in hand and not from memory. Our test
Destroying means a shredder at home, or a shredding service. If you pay for a service, ask how the paper is destroyed, where, and what it costs per box. We name none. If the owner of the papers has died, the destroy pile stays empty for now: set those papers aside in the box and read Clearing a house that isn't yours.
The recycle pile, and the photographs box
Recycle only paper with nothing personal on it, through your local program. Photographs are not paper for these piles. Take them out first and put them in their own box. Whether a photograph leaves the house is decided in The hard things. What to do with the ones you keep, including scanning prints, slides and negatives and keeping the originals, is the subject of the prints and slides chapter in Learn Digital Photo Care, which also covers handing a collection on.
Papers with their own reasons to keep Understand
Some papers are not on the IRS clock and not on yours. This table lists the kinds of paper we ask you to set apart, why each has its own reason to be kept, and who to ask. We have fetched sources for only two of the rows, and we say where a row has none.
| Kind of paper | Why it has its own reason | Who to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Birth, marriage and death certificates | They are the proof of the event, and replacing one means applying for it. | The office that issued it. If you do not know which, the county clerk's office can usually point you. No source in this manual's research states a rule, and we link no directory. |
| Deeds and titles (house, car) | They record ownership of a house or a car. | The office that recorded or issued the paper, and a lawyer for anything to do with an estate. No source in this manual's research states a rule. |
| Military discharge and service papers | They are the record of service. | The National Archives. Its home page offers a way to request military records for yourself or a family member (National Archives, Veterans' Service Records section). |
| Medical records and the papers that go with them | They record a person's care, and an insurer may ask for them. | The provider that holds them, and a clinician for what to keep. |
| Insurance policies, loan papers, and anything that supports a claim or a debt | The IRS page says insurance companies and creditors may require longer retention than the IRS does. | The insurer or creditor. |
| Wills, powers of attorney and the papers a lawyer drew up | They decide who has authority. Ask the lawyer where the original should be kept. | The lawyer who drew them, and a probate lawyer if the owner has died. See The three situations. |
The pattern is the same for every row. If you cannot say what a paper proves, who issued it or who might ask for it, put it in the keep-for-a-period pile with a pencil note and ask the role in the last column.
Mail that keeps arriving
If you are moving, the United States Postal Service has an official change-of-address form. It asks who is moving (an individual, a family or a business) and requires a mobile phone number for identity verification. The page does not say what to do about mail addressed to a person who has died. That is a question for the probate lawyer and the post office, and it comes up again in Clearing a house that isn't yours.
A longer retention table
The outline for this manual asked for a longer retention table by document type. We could not source one. The IRS table above is the only retention source we fetched, and the other rows rest on the issuing office or the party that may ask. If you want more rows, ask each one: the insurer, the lender, the clerk's office or your tax preparer. Write the answer next to the paper in pencil and move the paper to the keep-for-a-period pile.
A deceased person's papers
Which papers an estate needs is a question for the probate lawyer. Our list of papers to keep together, so that none is shredded by accident, is: the will and any trust papers, insurance policies, account statements, tax returns, deeds and titles, loan papers, recent bills and anything a lawyer or clerk has sent. Hand the box to the executor, or to the lawyer, and ask for the list of what they need. See Clearing a house that isn't yours.
Media nobody can read any more
Floppy disks, old tapes and drives that no computer in the house can open may hold photographs, documents or video. We have no source on reading them. The formats and long-term chapter in Learn Digital Photo Care covers photo file formats and moving to new drives. Keep the media in its own box and ask a local service whether it can be read before you decide to discard it. When you do discard electronics, the where it goes page lists the route.
The data still on the devices Understand
A phone, a tablet, a laptop, an external drive, a memory card and sometimes a printer or copier hold information about the people who used them. The Environmental Protection Agency's page on donating and recycling electronics gives one instruction on this: "Delete all personal information from your electronics" (EPA, Electronics donation and recycling). The page does not say how, and it does not list the devices. EPA guidance
What the same page does say is useful for the rest of the job:
- Remove batteries from electronics, because they may need separate recycling.
- Lithium-ion batteries, and devices that contain them, should not go in household garbage or recycling bins.
- Check for a recycling facility in your state or community, or search for donation and recycling options through manufacturers and retailers. EPA says it does not endorse the services it names.
Where each of those goes in your county is in What can't go to the thrift store and the where it goes table.
Make the list first
The list is the step most people skip. Walk the house with the inventory open and add one line for each of these:
- Phones and tablets, including the ones in a drawer.
- Computers and laptops.
- External drives, USB sticks and memory cards.
- Printers and copiers. Whether a given one keeps a copy of what it scanned or printed is a question for its maker's manual or support line; we have no source on it.
This list is ours; the EPA page names no device types. In the notes column write the status: listed, backed up, cleared, or still in use. Our list
Back up, then clear
Clearing is a deletion, and a deletion can be permanent. Our order is to copy what you want to keep first, then clear the device, then confirm that it is clear. How to do each of these is in the device maker's instructions and in Learn Digital Security. Its first chapter builds a list of your devices and accounts, its phone and tablet chapter covers locks and updates, and its backups chapter covers a copy you have tested. It does not give a wiping procedure that we can cite, so this manual gives none. Our order
If the device belonged to someone who has died, do not clear it yet. It may hold what the estate needs, and who may open it is a legal question. Put it aside and ask the probate lawyer.
See it: one box from Marguerite's desk See it
Marguerite Okonjo is 74 and is moving from Dayton to a two-bedroom apartment, with closing in eleven weeks. She works about four hours a week with her daughter (assumed in the case). She has no sale goal.
Known: eleven weeks, four hours a week, no sale goal. Assumed (ours, for the example): one box from her desk holds bank statements, a folder of utility bills, copies of old tax returns, a deed folder, a few appliance manuals and a recipe folder. She also has an old laptop she does not use, a printer, and a phone she keeps. Open: which statements and returns still matter for her taxes, which her tax preparer settles; and whether she can replace the deed, which the office that recorded it settles.
What she does. In an hour with her daughter she makes four piles. The recipe folder goes to the sentimental category in The hard things. The deed folder and the returns go in the keep piles. The appliance manuals for appliances she no longer owns go to recycling. The utility bills carry an account number, so they go in the destroy pile after a check. The bank statements go in the keep-for-a-period pile with a pencil note, "ask my tax preparer," because they might support a return. She lists the laptop, the printer and the phone in the inventory. She backs up what she wants from the laptop, then clears it before it leaves, and keeps the phone in use.
Conclusion, under these assumptions: one box is sorted into four piles and three devices are on a list, with the two open questions written down and owned by a named person. Nothing in this example says how long her bank statements must stay. That is the preparer's answer.
- IRS, How long should I keep records?: the retention periods and the instruction to check other purposes.
- EPA, Electronics donation and recycling: the instruction to delete personal information, and the battery notes.
- Learn Digital Security: the manual to use for backups and for securing accounts and devices.
Practice: one box, then the device list Practice
Minimum: one box into four piles, and every device on a line in the inventory. Time: about 45 minutes. Materials: four boxes or trays labeled with the piles, a pencil, sticky notes, and the inventory open on a phone or computer.
- Take one box and the four trays. Take the photographs out first and put them aside.
- Handle each sheet once. Put it in a tray. If you cannot say what it proves, it goes in keep-for-a-period with a pencil note.
- Check the destroy tray for anything that belongs to someone who has died. Move those back.
- Walk the house for devices. Add a line for each one. Write the status in the notes column.
- Choose the next device to clear, and back it up before you do.
Ask your tax preparer one question: which of the papers in the keep-for-a-period tray do you want to see for my return? Write the answer on each. Then schedule a second box. Timing the first one tells you how many sessions the rest needs.
Your situation Your situation
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does every sheet from the box sit in one of the four piles?
- Does every paper in the destroy pile carry something that needs destroying, and has nothing there been set aside for an estate?
- Is there a pencil note on each paper in keep-for-a-period saying who to ask?
- Is every device in the house on a line in the inventory, with a status?
- Is every device you are passing on backed up first and cleared before it leaves?
Worked example
Marguerite's box ends in four piles, with the bank statements marked "ask my tax preparer." Her laptop, printer and phone are on the inventory with a status each. Against the criteria, the open items are the two questions on the sticky notes, and each has a named person who settles it.
Common mistakes
- Reading the IRS table as a shredding schedule. If you are about to shred everything older than three years, stop. The table covers tax records only, and the other rows in the previous section have their own reasons.
- Clearing a device before backing it up. A deletion can be permanent. Copy first.
- Forgetting the drawer devices. A phone in a kitchen drawer counts. Walk the house with the list open.
- Shredding the owner's papers after a death. If the owner has died, the destroy pile stays empty until authority and the estate's papers are settled.
What is still unresolved
Which records matter for your own return is a question for a tax preparer. Whether a certificate or a deed can be replaced is a question for the office that issued it. How to clear a particular device is in its maker's instructions and in Learn Digital Security. The estate's papers are the subject of Clearing a house that isn't yours.