Sorting methods and dividing methods compared
Two tables. The first compares four ways to sort a room. The second compares six ways to divide belongings among people, round robin and lottery among them. Both are the manual's own synthesis; each row says what it suits and where it breaks.
Both tables are our own synthesis, labeled as such. No single source we read lists these methods as one set, and no source ranks them. Each row says what a method suits and where it breaks; where a publisher names a method, the third table says who. How to sort a room and Passing things to people explain how to choose and run one.
Four ways to sort a room
| Method | What you do | What it suits | Where it breaks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Room by room | Finish one room's doors before opening another. | One person's things, where most categories live in the room they are used in. | A category scattered through the house: you sort the tools in the garage without seeing the ones in the basement. |
| Category across the house | Gather every object of one kind (all the tools, all the paper) onto one surface, then sort it. | Categories that are scattered, and any category where duplicates are the question. | It needs a large flat surface, and the house looks worse before it looks better. Moving a category is itself lifting. |
| Four containers | Start with four labeled containers: keep, give away, throw away, not sure. Then send the give-away container to its doors. | A first pass through a room when you can't yet name the routes. | "Give away" hides four doors (person, donate, sell, special handling), so the container becomes the hallway box. |
| Keep-pile reversal | Take everything out of a space. Put back only what you choose to keep. What is left on the floor leaves. | A space where keep is far smaller than what is in it, and the space to put back into is measured. | The room is empty until you finish. An interrupted session leaves nothing usable, and it needs room for everything at once. |
Six ways to divide belongings among people
Agree the method before anyone names an object. A completed division is a family agreement, not a legal document.
| Method | How it runs | Suits | Breaks when | Leans on |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round robin by turn | The group fixes an order, often by a draw. Each person in turn takes one object, until the contested objects are gone. | Many objects of similar importance, with everyone present in the room or on a video call. | One object matters far more than the rest, so the first pick takes it. Someone cannot attend. | Equal count |
| Lottery | Draw lots for each contested object. A coin, numbered slips or dice all work if everyone watches. | A single object two or three people want, and nothing else decides it. | One person wants the object much more than another. A draw cannot register how much. | Equal chance |
| Written wish lists, collected in advance | Each person writes the objects they want, ranked if the group wishes, without seeing the others' lists. One person gathers them. An object named once goes to the person who named it; an object named twice goes to a second method. | People far apart, or a group where the loudest voice usually wins. | The person collecting is not trusted. Every list names the same three things. Someone does not write a list. | Need, and who asked, in writing |
| Colored stickers | Each person gets a color and a set number of stickers. Everyone walks the house and marks what they want. An object with one color goes to that person; an object with two or more goes to a second method. | Everyone is in the house, and the group wants to see where the interest is. | People are far away. Someone covers everything in stickers, which is why the number is fixed in advance. Stickers decide nothing in law (see the Limits box). | Who asked, in the open |
| Appraise and balance | A qualified appraiser values the objects. People take objects, and whoever takes more than their share pays or is credited the difference. | Objects with real money value, when the group holds to equal value. | The appraisal costs more than the objects are worth. The yellow bowl has no useful price. Money moving between people raises questions the manual cannot answer. | Equal value |
| Sell and split the proceeds | Sell the objects by one of the routes in Selling and divide what is left after fees in agreed shares. | A group that does not want the objects and wants the matter closed. | Someone wants a particular object. The shares are not equal under a will. Selling starts before authority is settled. | Equal value |
Who names each dividing method
| Method | Named by |
|---|---|
| Round robin by turn | Kentucky Extension, as "drawing lots": heirs take turns picking items (FCS5-481). ElderLawAnswers: draw box lots and take turns picking, changing the order each round. |
| Lottery | Montana State University Extension lists "shake dice" and "draw numbers" as family methods (MontGuide MT199701HR, slides). The University of Illinois Extension worksheet lists a "lottery method" with blank pros and cons (worksheet). ElderLawAnswers: names or numbers in a hat set the order in which heirs choose. Using a draw for each contested object, as we do, is our own distinction. |
| Written wish lists, collected in advance | ElderLawAnswers: heirs rank items by preference, an item with no competition goes to whoever chose it, and those who chose the same item may draw straws. Kentucky Extension, Montana State and ElderLawAnswers also describe a different thing: a list the owner writes and refers to in the will. The Illinois worksheet lists "preparing a list" without saying who prepares it. |
| Colored stickers | ElderLawAnswers only: one sticker on an item and it goes to that person; more than one and the family may revert to taking turns. |
| Appraise and balance | ElderLawAnswers only: appraisals, because with plain turns the first pick may take the most valuable item, and the holder of a high-value item may pay the others. Kentucky Extension advises an appraiser for valuable items so that all beneficiaries know the values, but does not describe balancing. |
| Sell and split the proceeds | ElderLawAnswers: sell the most valuable items and share the proceeds equally. Kentucky Extension lists garage sales, estate sales and public auctions as methods, without describing a split. |
These tables describe options; they do not recommend one. Which method suits a family depends on who is in the room, how many objects are contested and whether anything has real money value. Where a will, an executor's duty or a court says otherwise, that governs, and a probate lawyer settles it. ElderLawAnswers is a lawyer-referral publisher and University of Minnesota Extension sells its workbook; the other three pages are free extension publications.