Sentimental objects, collections, and a dead person's belongings
Sentimental things, collections and the belongings of someone who has died are the slowest objects in any house. This chapter says how to sort them last, how to keep what an object stands for without the object, and where the line with other people's claims falls.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. Sentimental objects: last, by category, in four ways
- 2. Collections, and gifts you didn't like
- 3. A dead person's belongings
- 4. Sorting while the owner is present, and children's things
- 5. See it
- 6. Practice
- 7. Your situation
- 8. Check your work
- 9. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Pick one kind of object that stops you, set a limit on how much of it you will keep, and record what it stands for before it leaves. You need no date, no helper and no other person's agreement for things that are yours alone.
- Pick one category, not one room. The cardigans, the letters, the tools, the quilts. Leave it for after the easier categories (sort them last, by category).
- Set a container count before you start. Decide how many shelves, boxes or feet of space this category may keep. Write it down (Deciding what to keep shows how to measure the space).
- Record the story for anything you photograph instead of keeping. Who, when, what it did. One or two sentences in the inventory note, in the owner's words if the owner is present (four ways to keep what an object stands for).
- Log what left. One line per group in Inventory, rooms and keep list, with the door it left by. If anyone else has a claim on an object, stop and go to Passing things to people first.
Minimum time: one category, in as many short sessions as it takes. Done when: one sentimental category is finished and its stories are written down.
1. Sentimental objects: last, by category, in four ways Understand
A sentimental object is an object whose value to you is what it stands for: a person, a time, a place, something you did together. The object and the thing it stands for are two different things, and a sort can treat them separately. That is the idea behind every technique in this chapter.
Sort these categories last and sort them by category, not by room. Last, because the doors are working, the space that remains is measured and the routes are booked, which leaves the decision about a sentimental object as only a decision about the object. By category, because a sentimental category (the letters, the cardigans, the tools) is scattered through the house, and the objects in it are easier to weigh against each other than against whatever happens to share a shelf. Our preference This is about the order of the work. We make no claim about how any of it will feel.
Four ways to keep what an object stands for without the object
This table is the manual's own synthesis. We don't attribute it to a source.
| Way | What you keep | What it needs | Where it stops |
|---|---|---|---|
| Photograph it | How it looked, and where it was. | A photo, filed so you can find it. Photographs: see the note below the table. | It keeps the picture, not the thing. It does not settle a claim anyone else has. |
| Write the story down | What it was for, who gave it, what it did. | One or two sentences, in the owner's words where the owner is present. | Only as good as the memory it is written from, so do it before the object leaves. |
| Keep one of a set | One object stands for the rest. | A place in the allotment (Deciding what to keep). | The rest still need doors. Which one to keep may be someone else's choice. |
| Keep a part | A square, a button, a handle, a label. | Very little space. | Cutting an object up can't be reversed. Don't do it to anything others have a claim on or that someone may value. |
Photographs are their own subject. Learn Digital Photo Care covers what happens to them once you have them: Dates, captions, people and places says where a caption is kept (a good place for the story), Choosing what to keep covers deciding which photographs stay, and Prints, slides and negatives covers scanning. This manual decides only which photographs leave the house; the other manual covers the rest.
"Photograph it and let it go" is for objects that are yours to let go. It is not a way to settle an object someone else has a claim on: a sibling, a co-owner, an heir, or the owner who is still alive and hasn't agreed. For anything contested, go to Passing things to people before the object leaves. The University of Minnesota Extension notes that belongings have different meanings to different individuals, which is the reason a photograph that satisfies you may not satisfy them (UMN Extension, Who Gets Grandma's Yellow Pie Plate?). Who has the authority to decide about a dead person's property is a question for a probate lawyer and the county clerk. Ask the authority
2. Collections, and gifts you didn't like
A collection is a group of objects gathered because they belong together: stamps, figurines, records, spoons. The difficulty is that the group and each piece answer different questions.
Handle a collection as one unit before you handle its pieces. Our preference
- List it as it stands. What it is, how many, where it is kept, in what condition.
- Photograph the whole, then the pieces you would want to find again. Do this before anything leaves, because a collection can't be rebuilt from memory.
- Decide the unit first. Keep all of it, keep a portion, or send it onward as a whole. Selling pieces one at a time can't be undone, so don't start until the question of value is answered.
- Pick one piece to keep if the rest go. That is "keep one of a set".
This manual doesn't price a collection and makes no claim about whether it is worth more whole or in parts. We can't tell from outside, and a list on a shelf can't either. Whether it is worth looking at is a question for a qualified appraiser. The Go deeper section below says when an appraisal is required by the IRS and what a qualified one is; the route for selling is in Selling.
Gifts you didn't like
A gift you didn't like leaves by a door like any other object. In our view, the giver's intent was met when the gift was given, and keeping the object doesn't continue it. Our preference There are two exceptions. If the giver is alive and expects to see it, or the object stands for something about the relationship, that is a conversation between you and the giver, not a rule. If it came from the dead person whose things you are sorting, treat it as one of theirs (next section), and don't decide it alone.
3. A dead person's belongings
Clothes, tools and unfinished projects are the slowest objects in a house. The reason is practical: more people have a claim on them, and the authority to dispose of them may not be settled. Three things come before sorting.
- Who has the authority. That comes from the will and the court, not from being the person who showed up. It is a question for a probate lawyer and the county clerk. Start with who has the authority, and for a whole house, Clearing a house that isn't yours.
- Who else has a claim. Anything more than one person wants goes to Passing things to people. The Haverford siblings, a fictional case in this manual, disagree about their father's workshop tools; those tools stay where they are until the three of them have a method.
- What can be sorted now. Everything nobody has claimed and nobody is waiting on.
| Kind | What makes it slow | What helps |
|---|---|---|
| Clothes | Each one is worn in a memory. | Keep one garment or one part, photograph the rest, write the story, then donate by Donating. |
| Tools | More than one person may want them, and they are heavy. Fuel, batteries and solvents in a workshop are special handling. | List them, ask before anything leaves, and get help lifting. See What can't go to the thrift store. |
| Unfinished projects | The object is half a plan. | Photograph the state it is in. Ask whether anyone can finish it. Keep one finished or part-finished piece. The rest takes a door. |
Workshops, attics and basements cause injuries. Get help with anything heavy or high, and stop before you are tired.
If grief is making it hard to start, the pacing advice is the same as for any hard category: shorter sessions, one category at a time, and a date on the next one. If it is more than that, a clinician is the right person to ask, and this manual is not a substitute.
4. Sorting while the owner is present, and children's things
When the owner is alive and in the room, the owner decides. Winnie Falk and her mother Ruth, fictional cases, are the example below. Ruth, 86, is moving to one room in assisted living with 11 linear feet of shelf, and she is present for every decision. Ruth is the owner and decides. Whether Winnie holds a power of attorney is left open here (assumed: she doesn't use it, because Ruth can decide); that is a question for a lawyer, and The three situations sets it out.
- Ruth holds each object and decides. Winnie asks, writes, carries and keeps time.
- Ruth sets how long a session lasts and can end it. The next one goes on the calendar before they stop.
- The shelf is in the room. The 11 feet are marked with tape, so Ruth sees what the space holds. When it's full, something comes off, and Ruth picks what.
- A decision made without Ruth isn't Ruth's. If an object has to be moved while she's away, it goes in the undecided box with a date, and she sees it first.
- Stories are written in Ruth's words, in the inventory note for that object.
Our order of categories (sentimental last) is a default. If Ruth wants to start with the photographs, she starts there. Our preference
Children's things kept for grown children
A box of a grown child's things takes up room in your measured space on their behalf. The conversation that settles it is one message, in writing: what you have (a list or photographs of each box), what you will keep for them (if anything), the date by which they should tell you what they want, and the door the rest goes to if they don't answer. Our preference A photograph of each box's contents lets a child who lives far away decide without traveling. Whether an adult will answer is theirs to say; the date and the default door are what let the sort go on either way.
Collections: when an appraisal is required, and what a qualified appraisal is
We don't price a collection. This section says only what two federal publications and one standards body state. The rules below are written for charitable donations. Whether any of it applies to your return is a question for a tax preparer. Ask the authority
- When the IRS requires an appraisal. For a deduction of over $5,000 for a noncash contribution, IRS Publication 526 requires a contemporaneous written acknowledgment, a qualified written appraisal from a qualified appraiser, and Form 8283, Section B. For a group of similar items, you consider the whole group, including items given to more than one organization (IRS Publication 526). Publication 561 says the same of a collection valued at more than $5,000 (IRS Publication 561). It adds that a household item not in good used condition, for which more than $500 is claimed, also needs a qualified appraisal.
- What a qualified appraisal is. Per Publication 526, an appraisal document that is made, signed and dated by a qualified appraiser in line with the substance and principles of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, with a valuation date within a stated window around the contribution and received before the return is due. One of its conditions is that it doesn't involve a prohibited appraisal fee, which Publication 561 describes, in general, as a fee arrangement based on a percentage of the appraised value.
- Who a qualified appraiser is. Per Publication 526, an individual with verifiable education and experience in valuing the type of property, who regularly prepares appraisals for pay, and who either holds an appraisal designation from a recognized professional organization or meets stated minimum education and experience requirements.
- What USPAP is. The Appraisal Foundation describes the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice as the national standards for real estate appraisal and other appraisal services, including personal property (The Appraisal Foundation, USPAP).
- Price guides. Publication 561 cautions that catalogs and price lists can be unreliable indicators of value and should be supported by other evidence. That is one reason this manual gives no price.
Outside those donation rules, the sources we hold don't say when an appraisal is worth its cost. Our reasoning: compare the appraiser's fee with what depends on the answer. If you can't say what depends on it, ask an appraiser before you engage one, in writing, what they would do and what they charge. Our preference Two directories list credentialed appraisers: International Society of Appraisers and American Society of Appraisers.
When the owner can't decide, or changes their mind
Put the object in the undecided box with the date of the next session (the undecided container). Don't decide for the owner to keep the session moving. If you need help the manual can't give, the Eldercare Locator connects you to local services for older adults and their families (Eldercare Locator).
5. See it See it
Winnie Falk and her mother Ruth are fictional, and the figures marked assumed are invented for this manual. Ruth, 86, is moving to one room in assisted living with 11 linear feet of shelf. She is present for every decision, and Winnie helps. They are sorting one category: the quilts.
Known: the 11 feet of shelf; Ruth decides. Assumed (Winnie's, for this example): Ruth made seven quilts. A folded quilt takes one foot of shelf, which Winnie measured with one. Ruth sets a limit of two quilts, 2 feet of the 11, before they start. Open: who gets each of the five that go (Ruth names them; if two people want one, Passing things to people settles it), and whether Winnie holds a power of attorney (assumed, not used).
| Step (assumed) | What happens |
|---|---|
| Limit set | Two quilts, 2 ft of the 11 ft. Written down before the first quilt is lifted. |
| All seven photographed | Each one, flat and with a label in the frame. |
| Ruth chooses two | She holds each one. Winnie doesn't choose. |
| Stories written | For each of the seven, Ruth tells it and Winnie writes it in the inventory note. |
| Five leave | Each goes to a person Ruth names. Anything two people want is a question for the dividing method. |
| Log | One line per quilt: the door, the name, the date. |
Conclusion, under these assumptions: the category is finished when two quilts are on the shelf, five have named people, and seven stories are written. The facts that could change it are who wants which quilt and whether Winnie's role needs a lawyer's answer. Nothing here tells either of them how it will feel.
- University of Minnesota Extension: Who Gets Grandma's Yellow Pie Plate?: the program page on family conflict over personal property.
- Learn Digital Photo Care: Dates, captions, people and places: where a story is kept with a photograph.
- Eldercare Locator: federal route to local help for older adults and their families.
6. Practice Practice
Minimum: one small category, one limit, one written story. Time: short sessions; the length is yours, and a category can take several. Materials: a phone or camera, paper or the inventory sheet, labels, and tape to mark the space.
- Pick the category. One kind of object, wherever it is in the house.
- Set the container count. The shelves, boxes or feet it may keep. Write the number before you open the first box.
- Check for claims. If anyone else has a claim on any of it, put it on the Who gets what sheet and set those objects aside for Passing things to people.
- Gather the category in one place. Get help with anything heavy.
- Choose what stays up to the limit. The rest take a door, one of the six from How to sort a room.
- Photograph what leaves, and write its story. Two sentences each is enough. Put the story in the inventory note.
- Log what left. The door, the name, the date.
A collection. List it, photograph the whole, and decide the unit before any piece moves. Ask a qualified appraiser about value; the section above says how the IRS defines one.
7. Your situation Your situation
8. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Did you set the limit before you opened the first box?
- Does every object that left have a door and a story, or a note that someone else has a claim?
- Did you check each object for another person's claim before it left?
- If the owner is alive, did the owner decide, and are the words in the notes theirs?
Worked example
Ruth's quilts: limit of 2 feet set first, seven photographed, two kept, five sent to people she names, seven stories written, one log line each. Against the criteria it passes, with two open facts named: who gets which of the five, and whether Winnie's role needs a lawyer.
Common mistakes
- Sorting a dead person's things before anyone has the authority. You'll notice it when someone asks "who said you could?"
- Photographing something that is contested and letting it go. You'll notice it when a sibling asks where it went.
- Setting no limit. You'll notice it when the category outgrows its shelf.
- Cutting an object into parts before anyone else has been asked. You'll notice it when it can't be put back.
What is still unresolved
This chapter doesn't settle who gets a contested object (Passing things to people), who has the authority over a dead person's things (a probate lawyer and the county clerk), what a collection is worth (a qualified appraiser), or what to do about papers and photographs in bulk (Papers, records and devices, and Learn Digital Photo Care).